Ratings · Measured, not sponsored

Yield aggregators

Every comparison in this category leads with the APY — the number the depositor controls least and the protocol controls most. We ranked on the thing you are really buying: who gets to move your money, and what happened the last time they got it wrong.

The short answer

Among the best DeFi yield aggregators we rated, Pendle leads at 8.72 out of 10, followed by Spark Savings (7.86) and Convex (7.24). The ranking is led by who can move your money and what happened when they did it badly, which carries 30% of the score; the displayed APY carries none directly. The one trade-off to understand is that every aggregator adds its own contracts and decisions on top of the protocol it deposits into, so you take on two layers of risk to earn one yield. Data measured on August 27, 2026.

The verdict

measured August 27, 2026
NO DISCRETION AT ALL

Buy a fixed return to a known maturity. No strategy can be changed under you — because there is no strategy. It is also the hardest product here to understand.

LONGEST CLEAN RECORD

Six years, $568m, no exploit, immutable core mechanics. Entirely dependent on one ecosystem.

MOST HONEST ABOUT FEES

States its fee schedule plainly and shows APY net of it. Also the protocol with two eight-figure incidents and two different outcomes for depositors.

What we did

We read what each protocol tells a depositor about where their money currently is, checked whether the advertised yield is net of the fees, and catalogued the incidents alongside what happened to the people who were in the vault at the time.

Researched by the ChainWatch Daily ratings deskMeasured How we rateSomething wrong? Tell us

A past bailout is not a policy you are covered by

Yearn, February 2021 ... $11m lost to a manipulated Curve pool ... repaid from treasury
Yearn, April 2023 ...... $10m lost to a legacy contract misconfigured since 2020 ... no make-whole

Same protocol. Two years apart. Whether depositors were made whole depended on the treasury, the moment and the decision — not on anything a depositor could have read in advance. That is why 30% of the score here is who holds discretion over your money and what the record shows they did with it.

Check what the vault actually holds

A large share of the capital in this category routes into the same handful of lending markets and staking tokens anyone can reach directly. Where that is true, the aggregator is charging a performance fee and adding a second layer of contract risk for automated compounding. Where it is not — fixed-maturity yield, vote-boosted rewards, genuinely leveraged strategies — it is doing something you could not do yourself, and the fee is a real price for a real service. Open the vault before you decide which one you are in.

01

The ranking

8 rated
#NAMESCORE

Click a row for the quick read, or open a company for its per-criterion scores and full profile.

Guide

Understanding yield aggregators

02

What a yield aggregator does

A yield aggregator takes your deposit, puts it into one or more other DeFi protocols, and reinvests what comes back. In exchange you receive vault shares rather than holding the underlying positions yourself.

Most vaults follow ERC-4626, a finalized Ethereum standard for tokenized vaults. Under it, your shares are themselves a token representing a fraction of everything the vault manages, and the value of each share rises as the vault's total assets grow. You enter by depositing an asset and leave by redeeming shares for it.

What happens in between is the strategy. Yearn's documentation describes vaults that run a single strategy or a collection of strategies that balance funds between them, with yield collected at each harvest and compounded back into the vault. The person or contract choosing those strategies is the part you are trusting.

03

How to choose a yield aggregator

Choose on control and visibility first, and on the rate last. Our weights, in reader terms:

  • Who moves your money, and what happened last time (30%). Protects you from a single key or a fast-moving manager redirecting your deposit, and from assuming a past bailout will be repeated.
  • Can you see what you own (22%). Protects you from a vault that shows a yield but not the positions behind it, or a trailing best-case number.
  • Size and survival (20%). A record through full market cycles is evidence in a category where the product is someone else's judgment.
  • What they take (18%). Protects you from fees that are not deducted from the number you were shown.
  • Chains and assets (10%). Rewards real deposits on a chain, not a long list of deployments.
04

Five different products under one label

The aggregators on this page do quite different things, and the risk you take depends on which one you pick.

  • Auto-compounders. Beefy and Yearn harvest rewards and reinvest them. Most useful on cheap chains, where manual compounding would cost more in gas than it adds.
  • Vote-boosted yield. Curve lets users lock CRV for one week to four years to boost their CRV rewards by up to 2.5x. Convex and Stake DAO pool that locked voting power and pass the boost to depositors who never lock anything themselves.
  • Fixed yield. Pendle splits a yield-bearing token into a principal token that matures at par and a yield token that decays to zero. Buying the principal token at a discount fixes your return to a known date.
  • Savings rates. Spark Savings pays a stablecoin rate set in advance by Sky governance, with no strategy for you to audit.
  • Leveraged strategies. CIAN runs looped lending and recursive staking, which multiply both the yield and the sensitivity to a price or rate move.
05

What yield aggregators charge

Aggregators charge a performance fee on yield, sometimes a management fee on assets, and the question that matters is whether the APY you see already has them removed. Yearn documents both clearly: the performance fee is taken from yield at each harvest, and the management fee is collected by minting new vault shares, which dilutes existing holders. Its fees are now set per vault; factory-deployed vaults charge 10% performance. Its displayed yield is net APY.

Others are less clear. Spark Savings charges depositors no fee. Stake DAO documents its fees across several product pages rather than in one place. Curated lending vaults built on Morpho's framework can charge up to 50% of yield and up to 5% of assets a year, so the specific vault's settings matter more than the brand.

One technical detail is useful when you check a vault yourself. Under ERC-4626, the simple share-to-asset conversion excludes fees, while the preview functions for withdrawing and redeeming include them. If the two numbers differ, the gap is what leaving will cost.

06

Risks, and what has gone wrong

Every aggregator is only as safe as the weakest protocol it deposits into, plus its own code. Yearn's two incidents show both halves: in February 2021 a manipulated Curve pool cost a DAI vault about $11m and the treasury repaid depositors; in April 2023 a legacy contract was drained for about $10m with no comparable make-whole.

The dependency runs in the other direction too. Convex has no exploit of its own on record, but Curve's July 2023 compiler-bug exploit was a risk event for Convex depositors because Convex sits entirely on Curve. Beefy has no protocol-level exploit, yet its vaults span 40 chains and hundreds of third-party farms. CIAN holds $261m in leveraged strategies with no audits listed in the main protocol registry we checked.

07

Getting out of a vault

Leaving a standard vault means redeeming your shares for the underlying asset, and how much you can take out at once depends on what the strategy can unwind. ERC-4626 vaults expose a maximum withdrawal per user, which can be lower than your balance when funds are deployed elsewhere.

Fixed-yield positions work differently. A Pendle principal token sold before maturity fetches whatever the market pays that day; held to maturity, it redeems at par for the underlying. If the vault simply routes into a market you could use yourself, such as one of the platforms in our lending rating, compare the direct rate before deciding the aggregator is worth its fee.

Before you choose

8 checks
  1. Open the vault page and write down which protocols it currently deposits into.
  2. Find out who can change the strategy, and whether a timelock delays those changes.
  3. Confirm in the protocol's own documentation whether the displayed APY is net of performance and management fees.
  4. Check how much of the quoted yield comes from token incentives rather than interest or trading fees.
  5. Compare the vault's rate with the rate of the underlying market used directly.
  6. Look up the aggregator's audits and incident history, and what depositors received after each incident.
  7. For leveraged or looped vaults, find out at what price move the position would be liquidated.
  8. For a fixed-yield position, note the maturity date and whether you might need to sell before it.

Terms on this page

8 terms
Vault share
The token you receive for a deposit. It represents a fraction of the vault's total assets and is redeemed for the underlying asset when you leave.
ERC-4626
A finalized Ethereum standard for tokenized vaults that defines how deposits, withdrawals, redemptions and share conversions work.
Strategy
The set of positions a vault uses to generate yield, chosen and changed by the vault's manager or governance.
Harvest
The moment a strategy collects its earned rewards, takes fees and reinvests the rest into the vault.
Performance fee
A percentage of the yield a vault earns, kept by the aggregator. Yearn's factory-deployed vaults charge 10%.
Management fee
An annual charge on assets under management. Yearn collects it by minting new shares, which dilutes existing depositors.
veCRV boost
Curve's reward multiplier, up to 2.5x, earned by locking CRV for between one week and four years.
Principal token (PT)
On Pendle, the part of a yield-bearing asset that matures at par on a fixed date. Buying it at a discount fixes the return.
08

How we scored this

weights sum to 100

A yield aggregator is a power of attorney over your money: you deposit, and somebody else decides which protocols it goes into, changes that decision without asking you, and takes a cut of what comes back. So the score is led by who holds that discretion and what has happened when they used it badly — not by the APY on the front page, which is the one number every comparison in this category leads with.

  1. Who moves your money, and what happened last time30%

    Who can change a strategy, how fast, and whether a timelock or a multisig stands between a compromised key and your deposit. Then every incident on record with what happened to depositors: Yearn’s DAI vault lost about $11m to a price-manipulated Curve strategy in February 2021 and repaid users from the treasury; a misconfigured legacy contract cost roughly $10m more in April 2023, with no comparable make-whole. Same protocol, opposite outcomes.

  2. Can you see what you actually own?22%

    Whether the current strategy and its underlying positions are published in a form a depositor can read, whether the advertised APY is net of fees, and whether historical performance is available rather than a trailing best number. A vault that shows a yield and not its composition is asking for trust it has not evidenced.

  3. Size and survival20%

    Total value locked at a stated timestamp, and how long the protocol has operated through full market cycles. In a category where the product is discretion, a long record is itself evidence.

  4. What they take18%

    Published performance and management fees, quoted from the protocol’s own documentation, and whether the displayed APY already has them deducted. Where a protocol’s fee schedule is not stated plainly in its own docs, that is recorded as a finding rather than estimated.

  5. Chains and assets10%

    Chains with real deposits and the range of assets supported, from public data at a stated timestamp.

Weights sum to 100. A criterion we cannot verify is deleted, not guessed. Full methodology →

Is there a free alternative?

For most stablecoin deposits, the aggregator is a fee on top of a rate you could take directly.

The largest vaults in this category route into the same handful of lending markets and staking tokens that anyone can access in two clicks. What you are buying is rebalancing and compounding, and what you are paying is a performance fee plus a second layer of smart-contract risk on top of the underlying protocol’s. That trade is worth it for complex, actively managed strategies and for gas-expensive compounding at small size. It is usually not worth it for parking stablecoins in a market you could have deposited into yourself — check what the vault actually holds before deciding which case you are in.

What changed since last time

1 entry
  1. 2026-08-27Category published.Aggregator comparisons rank on displayed APY. The APY is the number the depositor controls least and the protocol controls most.

Questions

8 questions

What am I actually buying from a yield aggregator?

Discretion. You deposit, and somebody else decides which protocols your money enters, changes that decision without asking you, and keeps a share of the result. That is a genuine service — rebalancing and compounding are work, and at small size on a cheap chain automated compounding really does add return. But it is also a second layer of smart-contract risk stacked on top of the underlying protocol’s, and a fee on a rate you could often have taken directly.

Which aggregator is safest?

On evidence, Pendle and Convex sit at the top for opposite reasons. Pendle removes the discretion entirely: you buy a fixed return to a known maturity, and no strategy can be changed under you. Convex has six years, $568m and no exploit, with immutable core mechanics — but it lives entirely inside the Curve ecosystem, so a Curve problem is a Convex problem.

If a vault gets exploited, will I be repaid?

Sometimes, and you cannot predict which time. Yearn repaid the victims of its February 2021 DAI vault exploit out of its own treasury, minting 9.7m DAI against YFI to do it. When a misconfigured legacy yUSDT contract was drained for about $10m in April 2023, there was no comparable make-whole. Same protocol, two years apart. Treat a past bailout as evidence about a moment, never as a policy you are covered by.

Is the advertised APY the yield I will receive?

Only where the protocol says so explicitly. Yearn’s documentation states that displayed APYs are net of its fees, which is the standard the whole category should be held to. Elsewhere you have to check whether the number is gross, whether it is a trailing best-case, and whether it includes token incentives that will not be there next month. A yield figure with no stated basis is marketing.

When is an aggregator not worth it?

When the vault routes into a lending market you could deposit into yourself in two clicks. Then you are paying a performance fee plus a second contract risk for automated compounding you could do manually. Open the vault, read what it actually holds, and if the answer is “the same market you were going to use anyway”, use that market instead.

What is the difference between yield farming and a yield aggregator?

Yield farming is the activity: depositing assets into protocols to earn interest, fees or reward tokens. A yield aggregator automates it for you, choosing the farm, harvesting rewards and reinvesting them. The aggregator saves time and, on cheap chains, can add return through frequent compounding. It also adds its own contract and its own decision-maker between you and the farm, which is the risk this rating weighs most.

Does auto-compounding really earn more?

Only when the extra compounding outweighs the fee. On a low-fee chain with a small position, automated harvesting several times a day can beat what you would do by hand. With a large position on Ethereum mainnet, compounding manually a few times a year usually costs less than a performance fee on every harvest. Run the comparison for your size and chain.

Can a fixed-yield position lose money?

Yes, in two ways. If you sell a Pendle principal token before maturity, you get the market price that day, which can be below what you paid. And the fixed rate is a claim on the underlying asset: if that asset loses its peg or its issuer fails, the fixed return is paid in something worth less. What Pendle removes is a manager's discretion, not the risk of the asset you chose.

Sources for the guide

4 sources

How this is funded

It is not. There are no affiliate links on this page or anywhere on this site, no paid placements and no sponsored positions. Nobody in this table can buy a place in it or influence a score. The full policy →